The Business Case for Women’s Economic Empowerment in Agricultural Value Chains

Women roughly account for half of the Ethiopian population. Considering their economic and social involvement, women’s unemployment rate (age 15+) in 2021 was 25% (in comparison to 11% for men)[1],  prevalence of severe food insecurity in the adult population is 51.8%, and literacy rate is 14.1% (compared to men 40.3%). In recent times, the only aspect they seem to nominally do well is the political aspect with 38.8% of seats in national parliaments held by women[2]. Most women, whether in the agrarian community or in urban settings, are still largely dominating in the household reproductive and care taker activities with minimal participation in public and productive activities.

We want to share some key insights and possible inclusive business models that we developed based on the outcomes of the different gender assessments we have conducted across several agricultural value chains.

Key gender-based constraints and opportunities

Women are less involved in marketing and control of income from high-value agricultural products such as avocado, banana, coffee, etc. That means, the higher the value of an agricultural product becomes in the market, the more it occurs that men want to control the marketing process and income generated from the sales of that particular high-value agricultural product. In contrary, the less valued the agricultural product becomes in the market, the less men are interested to engage in the production and marketing of that low-value product.

Although a low-value agricultural product creates room for higher involvement of women and a higher potential for women to control the income generated from it, the question is whether men will start to engage actively and take over control from the women at the time that initial low-value agricultural product becomes high valued? When we look at avocado, which was one of the value chains we analyzed with a gender lens, the answer is yes. Back in the day when there were only local avocado varieties available, avocado was not seen as high value and mainly produced by women. When the value of avocado in the market started to increase, men started to slowly dominate the chain. Today, women are usually engaged in avocado production as supporters of their husbands who are seen as the main avocado producers.

This means that a gender-transformative approach is needed to adequately address the gender inequality and power imbalance between men and women along the value chain. A gender-transformative approach consists of a combination of looking at social and cultural gender norms, roles, and power dynamics. By using  a gender-transformative approach, our study found that women disproportionately lack access to startup and operating capital compared to men due to their lower position in access and control of productive assets. Also, in most parts of Ethiopia, the bylaw of most cooperatives excludes women who do not have land and women who are married, because cooperative membership is limited to households that have land and only one member from such household can be a member, which usually will be the men as they are seen as the head of the household. Moreover, most rural women in male-headed households have limited access to production-related agricultural extension services and market information except when they are engaged as beneficiaries in a few project-based interventions that purposefully target both women and men. In addition, women have less market networks due to their lack of involvement in trading and inability to travel long distances in search of market.

Business opportunities that make the case for gender-inclusive business models

At the same time, our own evidence (gathered from the different gender assessments we have conducted over time) suggests that:

  • Women often outperform men when it comes to producing higher-quality agricultural products IF they have access to the same agricultural training and advice as men.
  • Women also perform better in seedling preparation activities, nurturing the growing plants at production stage, and in sorting and grading as they seem to have a better eye for quality.
  • Women are perceived as more trustworthy and loyal market actors including as suppliers, traders, retailers, and customers. Several male traders interviewed for our assessments reflected that they prefer women traders, if they are there, for the same trust reason but acknowledged their number is few.
  • Confirming the wide evidence existing around women loan repayment, many informal and formal loan providers (e.g. traders, relatives, MFI etc.) reflected that women tend to be more trustworthy than men in repaying their loans.

These are very important business opportunities for women that should be exploited more by support service providers from the government, private sector and NGOs. These support services could then assist women by providing access to finance (seed money / starting capital), access to agricultural training to produce high-quality agricultural products and access to training related to business and financial management; especially record keeping. However, the cultural norms regarding gender roles should also be addressed as this is an important factor for the success or failure of women-owned businesses. We found out that (especially married) women reported better business performance when they were positively supported by their husbands and the community. Supporting married women also seems to benefit other members of the household through increased income, job creation, better education and health etc. These cultural norms regarding gender roles could be addressed through a variety of awareness raising activities and dialogue sessions at community and household level, organized on the basis of what fits best within the local context, the financial and human resources available from the side of the support service provider to engage in these type of activities, and/or the level of sensitivity of certain cultural norms and gender issues.

Impact for Sustainability Consulting provides advisory services to value chain actors and support service providers from the government, private sector, and civil society in the form of gender equality (and social inclusion) assessments, analyses, evaluations, and inclusive business model identification to ensure that both men and women equally engage and benefit from their engagement at each stage of the value chain.

[1] Source: Geda, A. (2021). The Challenge of Unemployment and Youth Unemployment amidst Fast Economic Growth in Ethiopia. Website: https://includeplatform.net/wp- ontent/uploads/2022/04/The-Challenge-of-Unemployment-and-Youth-Unemployment-amidst-Fast-Economic-Growth-in-Ethiopia-1.pdf

[2] Source: UN Women Website, Link: https://data.unwomen.org/country/ethiopia

Scroll to Top